Well that didn’t last long. The Chicken Yoghurt recently marked Tony Blair’s new job as Middle-East peace envoy with a parlour game in which commenters might suggest other similarly implausible roles (Gordon Brown as Prime Minister, that sort of thing). Channel 4 gave us another hilarious example with last night’s documentary The War on Britain’s Jews?, in which professional bigot and poor man’s Melanie Phillips, Richard Littlejohn, took it upon himself to lecture us upon bigotry – specifically the “alarming resurgence” in anti-semitism.
Yet less than 24 hours after the broadcast of Littlejohn’s lazy, opportunistic and cynical broadcast, one of his principal contributors, Professor David Cesarani, had expressed measured but significant doubts about the helpfulness of Littlejohn’s sledgehammer approach to an important and sensitive topic:
”Littlejohn missed the indigenous and more insidious forms of anti-Jewish prejudice that can lead to exclusion and worse. Jews were readmitted to England and gradually given equality despite, not because of, the fact that they were Jewish. They were tolerated while they conformed to the dominant social and cultural forms and they trimmed their traditions so as to fit in.
The regimen of tolerance, embodied in liberal political culture, determined that there were good Jews and bad Jews. Watch out if you were assessed as the wrong type of Jew: too orthodox or too secular; too rich or too poor; too noisy and obtrusively Jewish or too keen to blend in. Worse, the assessment could flip-flop depending on circumstance.
This ambivalence, which is quite distinctive, makes it hard for British people to think of themselves as anti-Jewish although they are often thinking stereotypically even when they approve the Jewish presence. The same process has been applied to other immigrant groups, with significant historical variations.”
Of course, you’d never divine such a nuanced argument from the programme, which contented itself with serving up lurid clichés of anti-Semitism (desecration of cemeteries, smear campaigns in elections) as if these were a) generally representative of the discrimination which Jewish Britons experience and b) on a scale quite different from the hostility experienced by other religious and ethnic minorities. Littlejohn, like so many of those who cry crocodile tears over anti-Semitism, is far less interested in tackling such bigotry than he is in hijacking the issue to attack his usual targets, Muslims and the Left.
3 Comments
I quite enjoyed being lectured by Littlejohn, and thought it highly appropriate that Nick Cohen deigned to appear. After all, both of them spend their time whining about immigrants, calling for stiff measures against terrorists (up to and including torture) and pissing all over Lefties.
DecentVision, they can call this phenomenon, although I long for the day when they all just confess to being the flat-out fucking wingnuts they so obviously are.
Seriously, I can’t wait for the day when I visit Harry’s Place to discover they’re bashing FDR for the New Deal, finding tributes to Bush’s militarism in Harry Potter movies and blubbing about how a left-winger said something mean to them at a dinner party, and everyone agreed.
Actually, scratch that last one – Nick’s been at that tired bit of wingnut schtick for years.
Seriously though, did you see the look on Littlejohn’s face every time he called the Left “supposedly anti-racist”? I thought he was about to begin fucking his arse with the boom-mike and start furiously wanking himself while horrified mothers and children looked on.
“Bashing FDR for the New Deal”, FR? Coming right up. (Thanks to the wonderful Crooked Timber.)
I’m not surprised that British people exert prejudice towards Jews. For a start you have to knwo someone’s a Jew before you can exert prejudice and frankly, as Tony Blair appreciated fully, “we don’t do religion” in this country. Muslims, Scientologists, Sikkhs and all the other whack jobs out there- including the fucking Jesus squad- are all held in great suspicion by myself and most of my friends. As a functionally secular state, the UK remains the only place where you can worship whatever sky pixies you want without interference as long as you do it in the privacy of your own Mosque / Church / coven / etc. We know its crap and we won’t put up with letting you bang on about it without sneering at you and calling you names behind your back. Because you’re a whack job.
Here endeth thee rant.